How Do You Check a Business's Books Before Buying It?
By Kendall Maccagnan, CPA, CFP® and Financial Advisor in Tampa, Florida
Before buying a business, you want to make sure the financial numbers tell the full story. Just because a business looks profitable on paper doesn't mean it's making as much money as the seller claims. Start by comparing several years of tax returns, financial statements, bank deposits, and payroll records to make sure everything lines up. You'll also want to look for red flags like unpaid taxes, unusual expenses, or a business that depends too heavily on just a few customers.
A quality of earnings review can help you take a closer look at the numbers, understand which profits are likely to continue after the sale, and identify potential issues before you agree on a purchase price.
What Financial Records Should a Buyer Review?
A typical starting point is three years of business tax returns, profit and loss statements, balance sheets, bank statements, and payroll reports. Profit and loss reports show earnings over time and balance sheets show assets and liabilities on a particular date. Bank deposits show cash movement, but may not be 100% representative of the sales for the year as a sale can occur at one point in time and the collection of the cash at a later date.
A useful document set also includes year to date figures, detailed general ledger transactions, accounts receivable and payable aging reports, and sales summaries by customer. These documents can help to reveal collection issues and customer concentration.
Make sure you don't foreget about the balance sheet! A lot of people often focus on the profit and loss but the balance sheet is equally important and can reveal things like outstanding business debt. Remember, debt principal payments get recorded against the liability on the balance sheet, not on the profit and loss statement.
How Can Tax Returns, Profit and Loss Reports, and Bank Deposits Be Reconciled?
A good starting place could be comparing annual revenue and expenses on the seller's tax returns with the profit and loss reports for the same periods. Trace sales to invoices, processor records, and deposits.
Timing, bookkeeping adjustments, and loan proceeds can explain differences between tax returns and profit and loss reports. Card processors often deposit sales net of processing fees, while bank deposits may include sales tax collected, so deposits may not equal gross sales.
How Do Buyers Verify Seller's Discretionary Earnings and Add-Backs?
When you're selling your business, buyers want to understand how much money the business actually makes and how much of that income they can expect to keep after taking over. One way they do this is by looking at Seller's Discretionary Earnings (SDE). SDE starts with your business's earnings and adds back certain expenses that a new owner may not have to pay.
These adjustments are called add-backs. Common examples include personal expenses paid through the business, certain benefits you provide yourself as the owner, or unusual one time costs. However, just because you call something an add-back doesn't mean a buyer will agree with it. Buyers will want to see proof that the expense is legitimate and understand whether it will continue after they take over.
Here's how this looks in real life:
Say you pay yourself a $60,000 salary and want to add that amount back to your business's earnings. If the buyer plans to take over your responsibilities, that adjustment might make sense. But if they need to hire someone to do your job, they'll have to account for that person's salary. Otherwise, the business could appear more profitable than it really is.
The same goes for personal expenses paid through your business. Buyers may ask for receipts, financial records, and explanations to confirm which expenses were truly personal or unusual.
The better you can explain and support your add-backs, the easier it will be for a buyer to trust your numbers.
What Red Flags Appear During Small Business Financial Due Diligence?
When buying a business, there are a few red flags you'll want to watch out for. Some of the biggest include cash sales that aren't properly recorded, a business that relies heavily on just a few customers, unpaid payroll or sales taxes, and personal expenses mixed in with business expenses.
One major red flag is unreported cash income. Sometimes a seller will tell you the business makes more money than what's shown on their tax returns or financial statements because they receive cash payments that aren't reported. While that might sound appealing, you should be cautious. If the seller can't provide reliable records to support those sales, there's no easy way to confirm that income actually exists.
Another concern is customer concentration, which means a large portion of the business's revenue comes from just one or two customers. If one of those customers leaves after you buy the business, your revenue could drop significantly.
Unpaid taxes are another big issue. Before buying a business, you'll want to review payroll records, tax returns, and any outstanding notices from the IRS or state tax agencies.
In Florida, buyers may even become responsible for certain unpaid state taxes owed by the previous owner.
Keep in mind that a seller might have already paid a tax bill, be disputing it, or have failed to record it in their financial statements. That's why it's important to request supporting documents rather than relying on what the seller tells you.
What Does a Quality of Earnings Review Examine Before a Business Purchase?
A quality of earnings (QofE) review helps buyers understand how much money a business actually makes and whether those earnings are likely to continue after the sale. It goes beyond reviewing financial statements by looking at where the money comes from, whether the numbers are accurate, and what might change once a new owner takes over.
For example, a buyer might look at whether sales were recorded in the correct period, review unusual expenses, and check whether customers actually paid their outstanding invoices. They'll also take a closer look at the owner's add-backs to see if those expenses can reasonably be removed from the business's earnings.
A quality of earnings review helps you understand what you're really paying for and whether the business's reported profits tell the full story. It can also help you spot issues that could affect the purchase price or how the deal is structured.
Conclusion
When buying a business, it's important to remember that just because a seller says their business is profitable doesn't mean the numbers tell the full story.
Before making an offer, take the time to compare tax returns, financial statements, bank deposits, and other supporting records. Pay close attention to red flags like unpaid taxes, unusual expenses, or income that can't be verified.
You'll also want to understand which expenses can reasonably be added back to earnings and whether the business's profits are likely to continue after you take over. A quality of earnings review can help you identify potential issues and get a clearer picture of what the business is actually worth.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Financial Documents Should I Ask for When Buying a Business?
Common requests include three years of business tax returns, profit and loss statements, balance sheets, bank statements, and payroll reports. Accounts receivable aging, accounts payable aging, and customer level sales reports provide additional insight into cash collections and financial obligations.
How Can I Tell if a Small Business Is Hiding Revenue?
Unexplained differences between tax returns, sales records, and bank deposits can indicate incomplete records or potentially unreported revenue. Claims about cash sales that cannot be supported by reliable documentation deserve scrutiny, although discrepancies alone do not establish fraud.
What Is the Difference Between Seller's Discretionary Earnings and EBITDA?
SDE focuses on earnings available to an owner-operator and typically incorporates adjustments relating to owner compensation and benefits. EBITDA measures earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization. Both measures depend on accurate underlying records, and adjustments can materially change the earnings presented.
Is a Quality of Earnings Review Necessary When Buying a Small Business?
A quality of earnings review is a financial examination rather than a universal requirement for every transaction. Its usefulness depends on factors such as deal complexity, the reliability of financial records, and the uncertainty surrounding reported earnings. A review also differs from a financial statement audit.
Can a Buyer Inherit Unpaid Taxes When Purchasing a Florida Business?
Florida law provides for potential successor liability involving certain unpaid state taxes in connection with business purchases. The application depends on the transaction and statutory requirements, so an asset purchase does not automatically eliminate every potential tax exposure.
This content is provided for educational and informational purposes only and should not be construed as investment, tax, or legal advice. It is not intended as a solicitation or offer to provide advisory services in any jurisdiction where Off the Bay Wealth, LLC is not properly registered or otherwise permitted to operate. Information presented is based on sources believed to be reliable; however, accuracy and completeness are not guaranteed. This material is not intended to be a comprehensive analysis of all topics discussed. IRS provisions are subject to ongoing guidance and regulatory updates. Any financial decisions should be made in consideration of your individual circumstances, including your goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon. Investing involves risk, including the potential loss of principal.




Comments